PHL D87 - Essay Topics

Here are a set of possible topics for PHLD87. Please select one to write on. Alternatively, if you'd like to write on the topic of your presentation -- assuming you have done a presentation -- please let me know via email of your choice.

Your essay should be between 1800-2000 words. You should strive to both explain the issue you are dealing with as clearly as possible and critically/argumentative engage with the issue. This should involve both analysing and criticising existing arguments in the readings and attempting to advance the debate with your own arguments and point of view.

1. Libertarianism What is the doctrine of libertarianism? Describe and explain the general doctrine and Kane's particular version of it. Assess its strengths and weaknesses and consider whether it succeeds as a theory of free will.

2. Compatibilism. What is the doctrine of compatibilism? Describe and explain the general doctrine and Fischer's particular version of it. Assess its strengths and weaknesses and consider whether it succeeds as a theory of free will.

3. Libertarianism vs. Compatibilism.Specifically consider the primary differences between libertarianism and compatibilism with respect to the problem of free will. Is one of these theories superior to the other? If so, which is superior and why. If not, explain their equal failure.